Vol. I · Tuesday, July 28, 2026 RSS  ·  Search  ·  About

News and primary-source research on the Watchtower organization

Litigation

Topic
Sort
D.D.C. No. 24-cv-02523Confirmed

Judge revives Watch Tower's suit over Russia's seizure of the Witnesses' St Petersburg headquarters

Illustration: a sealed, undelivered envelope resting on a rolled property deed beside a ring of keys

A federal judge in Washington threw the case out in September 2025 — not on its merits, but because the lawsuit papers had never been validly delivered. On 23 July 2026 he undid that dismissal, giving the Jehovah's Witnesses' Pennsylvania corporation 180 days to serve the Russian Federation, its health ministry and the state institute now using the site, this time through diplomatic channels. Documents filed with the complaint valued the property at more than $30 million. As of that opinion the court had decided nothing about whether a U.S. court can hear the claim at all.

LegalReported

Oregon abuse suit against Watchtower takes an unusual route: federal trafficking law

Illustration: a legal complaint and scales of justice with two faint chain links

Meleah Thompson says she was abused as a child by men connected to her Oregon congregation in the early 1990s and that elders, told of it, invoked the two-witness rule and expelled her instead. Her suit, filed 20 July 2026, argues the coerced sexual acts were 'services' under the Trafficking Victims Protection Act and that Watchtower knowingly benefited from concealing them. The allegations are unproven and no defendant had responded on the docket as of 24 July.

D.N.J. No. 25-cv-01459Confirmed

UPDATE: Jehovah's Witnesses drop their appeal in a 1999 New Jersey tax-deal fight, leaving the federal dismissal to stand

Illustration: a sealed contract on a municipal ledger beneath scales whose pans are two courthouse doorways

A federal judge dismissed the congregation's bid to escape a 1999 payment-in-lieu-of-taxes deal on its Turnersville assembly hall, ruling only that a federal court is the wrong forum — she decided nothing about whether the hall is tax-exempt. The congregation appealed, then dropped the appeal on 21 July 2026, the day its opening brief was due, leaving that dismissal to stand.

Kings County, Index No. 522573/2026Confirmed

UPDATE: Brooklyn suit alleges 1980s abuse at Bethel, using New York City's new gender-violence look-back window

Two of three defendant organizations have now appeared through counsel in this unproven Brooklyn abuse suit; the judge will decide the plaintiff's anonymity request on the papers, not at a hearing. Filed 16 June 2026 under a January 2026 amendment reviving decades-old claims and extending liability to institutions.

LegalReported

UPDATE: Judge paused Brazilian woman's $100M abuse suit against Watchtower's Governing Body in May 2026

A judge paused this unproven $100 million case on 4 May 2026 at the Governing Body's request. The complaint, filed in Manhattan federal court on Nov. 12, 2025, alleges a Circuit Overseer abused Stella Cristina Gomes De Souza beginning at age 12 in Brazil and that Watchtower routed reports internally. The plaintiff asked the judge to reconsider on 18 May. A pause is not a dismissal. This account runs to the docket's last entry, 1 June 2026.

LegalConfirmed

Ordered to hand over its 'known child molester' files, Watchtower settled two New York abuse suits over the same man

Illustration: a document folder with a broken seal beside scales of justice

In sister Child Victims Act cases over Robert Warne, a ministerial servant at a Middleport, N.Y. congregation, a court denied Watchtower's bid to shield its nationwide reports of known abusers and pierced clergy privilege over his confession letter — before both suits settled in 2026. The Governing Body was dismissed from one case and kept in the other.

The $40 million judgment names one man who did not contest it; the church's separate settlement stays sealed.Confirmed

A Hawaii Judge Awarded $40 Million Against a Former Jehovah's Witnesses Elder. It Was Not a Verdict Against the Organization.

Illustration: scales and gavel beside an island motif

In 2023, Judge Dean Ochiai awarded a survivor known as N.D. $40 million against Kenneth Apana, a former Makaha congregation elder who did not defend the suit. The congregation and its entities settled separately and confidentially.